Coaching vs Managing: What's the Difference and When to Use Each?

Coaching and managing both advise and develop employees, but their methods and goals differ.

For a productive and motivated workforce, each style's strengths and goals must be recognized.

Let's compare coaching with managing, discuss their roles in businesses, and discover when to use both to improve team performance and growth.

What is Coaching?

Coaching can help unlock your employees' full potential and foster their growth.

It's all about having coaches who offer guidance, help set goals, and provide constructive feedback to boost skills and performance.

The beauty of coaching is that it encourages team members to take ownership of their own development, promoting self-awareness and a sense of responsibility.

Through coaching, you shouldn't just aim for growth; you should cultivate a culture of perpetual learning and empowerment within your organization.

Coaching comprises of several advantages that are essential to modern leadership.

Effective coaching motivates, engages, and satisfies employees. When employees believe their executives care about their success, they are more loyal to the company.

It also encourages people to take on new tasks without fear and doubt, which fosters innovation and flexibility.

1. Coaching helps employees discover their potential

Coaching fosters self-discovery and encourages employees to explore their unique abilities and potential. Coaches assist employees in discovering their strengths and weaknesses in one-on-one sessions, empowering them to grow. Self-discovery instills ownership and accountability and a development mentality in employees, encouraging them to learn and improve.

2. Improves employee engagement

Employees that are engaged are more dedicated and driven. Companies that use coaching reported a 25% increase in engagement.

Coaching zooms in on individual development, making each employee's tasks feel truly meaningful. Leaders who genuinely value and support their team members are rewarded with increased loyalty and dedication, resulting in higher retention rates and reduced absenteeism.

3. Helps with tailor-made skill development

Each employee has distinct strengths and growth requirements. Coaching lets leaders customize their approach. Coaches may give focused feedback, training, and tools to help employees overcome problems and realize their full potential by identifying areas for development.

4. Provides a continuous learning culture

Coaching promotes ongoing learning and progress in organizations. Employees with a growth mentality are more open to criticism, measured risks, and new ideas. Learning fosters creativity and innovation, advancing the company in a fast-changing commercial environment.

5. Leads to better performance and productivity

Coaching has a direct and positive impact on performance and productivity. When employees receive training and guidance, they gain confidence and competence.

In fact, studies have shown that 86% of organizations witnessed significant improvements after embracing a coaching culture, highlighting its effectiveness in enhancing organizational performance.

This increased competence leads to improved efficiency and productivity, benefiting both individual team members and the organization as a whole.

6. Enhances leadership development

Coaching includes leadership development as well as employee development.

Managers become better mentors and motivators by using coaching ideas. According to a study by Gitnux, 80% of leaders believe they need coaching to better support their growth and development.

Managers with strong coaching abilities may inspire and encourage their colleagues, creating a supportive and respected workplace.

7. Better communication and collaboration

Leaders and employees communicate more openly with good coaching. Regular counseling sessions improve relationships and resolve disputes via constructive criticism and meaningful interactions. This enhanced communication improves teamwork, problem-solving, and decision-making.

As per the same study by Gitnux mentioned above, executives who received coaching reported

• Increased self-awareness
• Improved communication skills and
• A better ability to control emotions

What Exactly is Managing?

Management involves overseeing day-to-day operations, ensuring efficient task completion, and allocating resources to achieve organizational goals.

Managers play a pivotal role in organizing workflows, setting performance standards, and making decisions aligned with the company's objectives.

In essence, management prioritizes stability, policy enforcement, and achieving predefined outcomes. It's a more directive approach that holds team members accountable for their performance while maintaining a structured environment.

Well-functioning organizations depend on good management.

Managers provide employees with structure, direction, and clarity to complete duties efficiently. They help create and maintain a productive workplace, enforce regulations, and optimize resource allocation.

Without experienced managers, corporate objectives and performance consistency are difficult to achieve.

1. Efficient organizational structure

Effective management sets defined roles and duties. It optimizes job allocation, reducing duplication and streamlining procedures. This ordered structure boosts efficiency and optimizes resource allocation to attain goals.

2. Performance measurement and accountability

Establishing clear measures and objectives for employees helps manage performance. It lets managers track progress and evaluate team and individual performance.

Managing ensures that everyone works toward common goals and contributes to the organization's success by keeping employees accountable for their accomplishments.

3. Strategic decision-making and controlled risk management

Managers make crucial decisions that affect the organization's operations and future. Effective management comprises risk assessment, alternative analysis, and educated decision-making to guide the company. Leaders prevent problems and guarantee long-term stability through controlling risks.

4. Resource allocation and budgeting

Effective resource allocation and budgeting are responsibilities of managers for diverse projects and initiatives. They must balance opposing demands to disperse resources where they may have the most impact. Skillful resource management helps financial stability and expansion ambitions.

5. Conflict resolution and team dynamics

To manage well, it is important to handle issues and promote healthy team dynamics. Managers resolve disagreements to encourage collaboration and understanding. Managers create a harmonious workplace to promote a favorable culture and engaged employees.

6. Compliance and regulations

Managers ensure the organization follows legal and regulatory obligations. Protecting the company's reputation and avoiding legal issues requires compliance with laws and industry standards. Skilled management maintains stakeholder trust by operating ethically and responsibly.

7. Crisis management and adaptability

Effective crisis management and adaptability need managers to guide the organization through uncertainty during times of crisis or unexpected obstacles. They must act quickly to defend the company's interests and help employees in tough situations. Crisis management shows resilience and adaptation, helping the company withstand storms and grow.

8. Performance development

Manage employees by offering regular feedback and assistance for progress. Managers identify development areas and provide training, mentorship, and coaching. Employee development improves morale, productivity, and work satisfaction.

For example, ThriveSparrow offers managers a quick way to gauge their team's engagement and provide regular feedback using research-backed survey questions.

Experience the convenience of ThriveSparrow: Elevate team engagement and feedback instantly with research-backed surveys!

Get Started

Understanding the major differences between coaching and managing is crucial to understanding their importance. Let's look at 4 key differences at a glance.

1. Coaching promotes empowerment, encouragement, and self-directed progress. Instead, management emphasizes work completion and monitoring with a directed style.
2. Coaching focuses on personal growth and potential. However, managing prioritizes results and organizational goals.
3. Coaches often encourage open communication and cooperation via participatory and facilitative leadership. Managers may use a more authoritative approach to complete duties effectively.
4. Coaching is usually longer-term and focuses on employee development. However, management prioritizes short-term performance and operational results.

A good mix of coaching and management that wholeheartedly benefits your employees can be termed as effective leadership.

Explore advanced team leadership looks like from six years of valuable experience.

Use coaching to empower employees in skill development, encourage a growth mindset, and navigate complex challenges. When aiming to build trust, collaboration, and a culture of continuous improvement, coaching becomes a valuable tool. Coaching is used to recognize high-potential talents, providing them with the guidance needed to become effective leaders within the organization.

Guidance for Leaders/Managers/HRs: Incorporate coaching when aiming to cultivate a workplace culture that values innovation, self-driven progress, and individualized development. Identify employees with high potential and use coaching to nurture their leadership capabilities.

Management is crucial for scenarios requiring structure, efficiency, and adherence to set procedures.

Employ management when clarity, quick results, and task completion are the immediate priorities. It's the preferred approach for meeting deadlines, ensuring compliance, and maintaining consistency.

Managers play a pivotal role in providing direction and control, making management essential for maintaining day-to-day operations and achieving short-term goals.

Guidance for Leaders/Managers/HRs: Utilize management when seeking streamlined processes, clear expectations, and adherence to organizational policies. This approach is effective for scenarios demanding a structured environment and when immediate results are critical.

Balancing coaching and management

In the world of business, coaching and managing are like two sides of a coin. They're both indispensable, and the secret sauce lies in blending them effectively while keeping an eye on the unique dynamics of your team and organization. It's akin to fine-tuning a well-oiled machine to ensure it hums with productivity and innovation.

Great leaders understand that the magic of excellent coaching lies in its ability to motivate and engage employees, while good management ensures that the wheels of your operation run smoothly. These two leadership styles aren't adversaries; they're collaborators, working together to unleash your team's full potential and navigate the ever-changing terrain of today's business landscape.

1. What are the benefits of coaching in management?

Coaching and managing are two very different terms. But, making coaching a part of the management process can have several fruitful benefits.

a. Coaching helps managers become better and more effective leaders by enhancing their communication and decision-making.

b. Managers can provide better support and motivation to their employees, thereby increasing productivity and job satisfaction.

c. Coaching enables managers to improve their active listening, thus helping build better relationships with their employees.

d. Coaching helps managers identify employees with high potential and help nurture their growth.

e. With improved communications and a harmonius work environment, organizations will benefit from more efficient operations and increased innovation.

2. What is coaching leadership style?

The coaching leadership style empowers managers to adopt a leadership approach focused on building stronger relationships and fostering the career growth of each individual. In such a role, managers become mentors for mentees, guiding them towards a unique career path and unlocking endless opportunities for development.

3. What are the coaching skills necessary for managers?

Coaching skills for managers include:

1. Providing guidance and support for employees.
2. Defining clear, achievable objectives.
3. Providing constructive feedback.
4. Fostering self-awareness and responsibility.
5. Tailoring coaching to each individual's needs.
6. Building trust and open dialogue with their team.
7. Fostering and nurturing a growth mentality within the team.
8. Improving themselves to becoming better mentors and motivators.
9. Helping improve teamwork and decision-making.